Rate Super Smash Bros Brawl here

Categories:

1.Graphics: How good are the Graphics, Be sure to consider all parts of the game

2.Presentation (Sound, Controls, and Online): How good do the menus look, and how good does the sound (Music and sound effects) and Controls immerse you in the game. How was the Online mode?

3.Gameplay: Is the game fun to play? Too Short? Too Easy?

4.Replayability: Is the game worth playing over and over again?

On a scale of 1-10 and average ur score out

1. Graphics-9.5 (very good graphics for the wii)

2. Presentation-9.7 (lots of music, 4 different controls, wi-fi is solid but laggy at times)

3. Gameplay-9.6 (very entertaining and SSE is solid)

4. Replayibility-10 (very replayable especially if u have friends to ownand wi-fi)

Average- 9.7

ok so

1.Graphics 8.5 pretty good for wii but i've seen better and some things get alot more detail then others

2.Presentation 9.5 music is great with the variety and there r four different control types to choose from only thing i would say is the online could be better

3.Gameplay 9 the game is great to play although i don't like the physics as much as melee sse isn't that good but i guess its better then adventure

4.Replayability 10 its packed with extra features and just normal brawls should keep u busy for a long time its pretty much a game built around replayability

5.Average 9.25 or 9.3 rounded to one decimal

ps im only going into half points in my reviews not down to the decimal

My Brawl Review:

Graphics: 8.2 -- Excellent Character Detail, Stage Detail lacking, explosions unrealistic

Presentation: 8.5 -- Menus aren't as good as melee, Wi-Fi is very generic, doesn't include Voice Chat, 4 Different Controls is a plus, Excellent Customization of Controls and Music

Gameplay: 9.2 -- SSE is an ok part of the game, but the multiplayer mode makes it look bad. VC Demos are a nice addition to the game

Replayability 10 -- Certainly a game i'll be playing a year from now

Average: 9.0 out of 10

SmashHero24's overthought review

Graphics: Ok, as far as a Wii game goes, this game has one of the best graphics on the console. Compared to the PS3 and XBox360, however, the graphics are still far from perfect. Thus it gets a....
8.8/10

Presentation: The game has over 150 songs that have customizable appearence rate allowing you to choose your favorite songs to always appear or just appear more often. The game also has customizable controls to play how you wanna play. As for online goes, the game isn't region locked. This is a good thing but has it's cons. Lag can be TERRIBLE when playing With Anyone mode, and even when just playing with friends in Europe. Speaking of With Anyone mode, without the ability to choose how you wanna play, and no choice of Stock, it seriously falls behind in online games nowadays. There's not even a ranking system. How are you supposed to know how good you are? Overall, it's okay, so it gets...
8.4/10

Gameplay: The game has been toned down in Competitive play...a lot. Most matches are one sided, and there is no longer much to master. Sakurai really effed up the gameplay. You eventually realize all the matches are kind of the same...gets very repetative. Not to mention the small roster. I expected a larger roster of at least 45. Not to mention the clonage. Luckily, he managed to include the SSE. Subspace saved the game from sucking. Adventure mode was toned up and was fun all the way through. It had a thcik, solid plotline, respectable cutscenes, and included almost every character in teh main storyline. Stage builder was also a big bonus. So overall, it deserves...
8.6/10

Replayability: This game is usually known for it's replayability. Yet, I'm feeling it less in this installment. Like I said, it gets repetative. All you see is Snake and MetaKnight, you know? Well, luckily, it's mostly still there! Overall...
9.8/10

Overall Score (not average): 9.2/10

Tommarow's sexy-ass review: Legend of Zelda: Twilight Princess

Last edited by SmashHero24 on Fri Nov 14, 2008 2:59 pm; edited 1 time in total

We decided we had to use averages, to be more fair, so i guess Smash's score is 8.9?

Linkrules08 wrote:We decided we had to use averages, to be more fair, so i guess Smash's score is 8.9?

Ehh...yea...
Did you actually read my whole review? I put my heart and soul into that...
I read yours.

SmashHero24 wrote:

Linkrules08 wrote:We decided we had to use averages, to be more fair, so i guess Smash's score is 8.9?

Ehh...yea...
Did you actually read my whole review? I put my heart and soul into that...
I read yours.

yeah, it's one of the best reviews i've seen yet in terms of details and reasoning.

wat about mine for mkw

It's amazing how many people who put at least above a 9.5 for replayability don't play the game anymore.

Linkrules08 wrote:

SmashHero24 wrote:

Linkrules08 wrote:We decided we had to use averages, to be more fair, so i guess Smash's score is 8.9?

Ehh...yea...
Did you actually read my whole review? I put my heart and soul into that...
I read yours.

yeah, it's one of the best reviews i've seen yet in terms of details and reasoning.

i think my cod5 one has taken that crown away